20 Staff Win as Appeal Court Orders PenCom to Pay ₦10m Damages
The Abuja Division of the Court of Appeal has awarded ₦10 million in costs against the National Pension Commission (PenCom) for engaging in unfair labour practices against 20 aggrieved workers.
In a unanimous judgment delivered in appeal number CA/ABJ/CV/830/2024, a three-member panel led by Justice Bilkisu Bello Aliyu, with Justices Donatus Okorowa and Oyebisi Omoleye Oyewumi concurring, ruled that the appeal filed by the workers was meritorious.
The appellate court subsequently set aside the June 13, 2023 judgment of the National Industrial Court, which had earlier dismissed the workers’ claims in their entirety.
Background
The dispute arose after the affected workers were issued letters of employment by PenCom and resumed duty on May 2, 2017. However, despite reporting for duty, they were neither deployed to any department nor assigned responsibilities.
Court documents revealed that the workers were instructed to “tarry” for further directives—orders that never materialised for years, leaving them without salaries or clarity on their employment status.
The claimants informed the court that they had resigned from their previous jobs based on PenCom’s offer, only to be left without pay or engagement.
Court Findings
Delivering the lead judgment, Justice Oyebisi Omoleye Oyewumi held that the recruitment process—including advertisement, interviews, and issuance of employment letters—constituted a valid and binding contract.
The court emphasised that admitted facts require no further proof, affirming that a contractual relationship existed between the parties and imposed legal obligations on PenCom.
It described the prolonged inaction of the commission as unjustifiable and ruled in favour of the workers.
Orders of the Court
The appellate court allowed the appeal and nullified the earlier decision of the lower court.
It also awarded ₦10 million in costs against PenCom, citing the “unnecessary and unwarranted rigours of litigation” endured by the workers since the suit was filed in 2022.
Reliefs Sought
In the originating suit marked NIC/ABJ/188/2022, the workers had sought several reliefs, including:
Recognition as employees under the Pension Reform Act 2014 and Public Service Rules
Payment of all outstanding salaries, arrears, and allowances
Promotion to appropriate positions within the commission
Protection from alleged harassment and obstruction in the course of their duties
They also asked the court to declare PenCom’s actions as unfair labour practices, discriminatory, and in violation of existing laws.
Implications
The judgment reinforces the principle that employers, including government agencies, are bound by employment contracts once established and cannot evade their obligations through inaction.
Legal analysts say the ruling may serve as a reference point in similar labour disputes involving public institutions in Nigeria.




