A new national poll has reignited one of the most divisive debates in American politics: where does President Donald Trump rank among U.S. presidents?
According to a recent Yahoo News/YouGov survey, 40% of Americans consider Trump the “worst president in U.S. history,” while 12% describe him as “worse than average.” By contrast, 12% rate him as the “best” president, and 21% say he is “better than average.”
The findings have sparked intense debate across political circles, social media platforms and news outlets, underscoring the deep divisions that continue to shape perceptions of Trump’s presidency and political legacy.
The survey also found that 49% of respondents believe Trump is doing a worse job than former President Joe Biden, while 41% say he is performing better. Independent voters were among the most critical groups surveyed, with a majority indicating that Trump is underperforming compared to his predecessor.
Trump’s supporters reject such rankings, arguing that his policies on immigration, trade, border security and economic nationalism continue to resonate with millions of Americans. They point to his enduring influence within the Republican Party and his loyal voter base as evidence that he remains one of the most consequential figures in modern American politics.
Critics, however, cite concerns over economic management, political polarization, legal controversies and the aftermath of the January 6 United States Capitol Attack as reasons for their negative assessment of his presidency.
The debate extends beyond public opinion polls. In the 2024 edition of the Presidential Greatness Project Survey, a survey of presidential scholars ranked Trump last among U.S. presidents. Supporters have dismissed such assessments as reflecting academic and ideological biases rather than broader public sentiment.
Historically, the title of “worst president” has often been contested. Historians have variously criticized figures such as James Buchanan, Andrew Johnson, Warren G. Harding and Herbert Hoover for different failures in leadership.
Presidential reputations have also changed dramatically over time; for example, Harry S. Truman left office with low approval ratings but is now widely regarded by historians as one of the more effective presidents of the modern era.
Ultimately, whether Trump is viewed as the worst president in U.S. history depends largely on the criteria used—economic performance, constitutional leadership, foreign policy, political conduct or long-term national impact.
The latest polling highlights not a settled verdict, but the extraordinary polarization surrounding a president whose legacy remains fiercely contested.




