11 Judges Reportedly Received N3.7bn Bribes in Two Years – Report

11 Judges Reportedly Received N3.7bn Bribes in Two Years – Report

News Media Nigeria
Court-logo
Highlights
  • 11 Judges Reportedly Received N3.7bn Bribes in Two Years – Report

 

 

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

11 Judges Reportedly Received N3.7bn Bribes in Two Years – Report

Advertisement
nlngnlng

A new report has raised concerns over corruption in Nigeria’s justice system, revealing that 67 per cent of prosecutors and 52 per cent of judges allegedly collected bribes, with both figures more than doubling between 2019 and 2023.

The report, released on Tuesday by the Platform to Protect Whistleblowers in Africa (PPLAAF), also disclosed that 11 of the 124 judges interviewed in a 2020 survey by the Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission (ICPC) admitted receiving bribes totalling N3.7 billion over two years.

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

Titled Judicial Corruption in Nigeria: Causes and Consequences, the report examined how bribery, political interference, external pressure and manipulation of judicial procedures continue to undermine the administration of justice in the country.

Findings drawn from surveys conducted by the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) and the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) identified prosecutors as having the highest bribery prevalence among the public officials surveyed.

The report also cited findings by the Auditor-General of the Federation that N4.8 billion was misappropriated or unaccounted for by federal courts between 2012 and 2015.

According to the report, judicial corruption is weakening efforts to prosecute politically exposed persons, recover unexplained wealth and strengthen accountability, while creating a justice system where wealthy litigants can secure favourable treatment at the expense of ordinary Nigerians.

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

Journalists Urged to Investigate Judges’ Unexplained Wealth

Speaking during the virtual launch of the report, governance and anti-corruption researcher Matthew Page urged investigative journalists to scrutinise the unexplained wealth of judges, particularly senior judicial officers, to uncover possible corruption.

Responding to a question on how judicial corruption could be exposed without whistleblowers, Page said journalists should investigate judges whose properties, foreign assets and lifestyles appeared inconsistent with their legitimate earnings.

He argued that investigating unexplained wealth could provide a faster route to identifying potential corruption than waiting for whistleblowers to provide direct evidence.

“We can wait for whistleblowers to sort of give us those smoking guns. But what is, I think, an easier and, in a sense, quicker method to finding out where there are problems is looking at this issue of unexplained wealth,” he said.

Page urged journalists to document the assets, property ownership and lifestyles of senior judges and compare them with their known earnings and career histories.

He maintained that judges, as senior public officials entrusted with public responsibilities, should be subjected to scrutiny over the sources of their wealth.

“They are public figures; they are very senior public officials endowed with the public trust, and so therefore, it is right that they come under scrutiny for their wealth or unexplained wealth,” he added.

Report Highlights Delays in High-Profile Corruption Cases

The report identified procedural irregularities, prolonged court proceedings and preferential treatment in high-profile cases as practices undermining anti-corruption prosecutions in Nigeria.

It cited cases involving former governors Orji Uzor Kalu, Chimaroke Nnamani and Willie Obiano, as well as former pension reform official Abdulrasheed Maina, as examples of how judicial dysfunction and suspected corrupt interference could weaken accountability.

On Kalu’s case, the report recalled that the Supreme Court nullified his conviction in 2020 on a technical ground after a 12-year trial, despite a 2015 law expressly allowing the trial judge to conclude proceedings.

It noted that six years after the conviction was nullified, Kalu had yet to be retried.

Page also identified weak enforcement of existing laws as a major contributor to delays in Nigeria’s judicial system, particularly in cases involving survivors of sexual and gender-based violence.

Responding to concerns about repeated court appearances and prolonged proceedings faced by young survivors seeking justice, he said the problem was not entirely attributable to corruption.

He pointed to the Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA) 2015, which was introduced to accelerate criminal proceedings and prevent unnecessary delays.

According to him, the provisions of the law have not been adequately implemented by the judiciary.

“Before we start about new solutions, let’s fully implement the solutions that we already have and demand that Act be obeyed and held to more than it currently is,” Page said.

EFCC, Judicial Case Allocation Also Under Scrutiny

Page acknowledged that anti-corruption agencies, including the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), could sometimes be ineffective or compromised, despite demonstrating innovation in pursuing politically exposed persons in other instances.

He cited the case involving former Rivers State Governor Peter Odili, arguing that the EFCC’s failure to challenge a perpetual injunction within the stipulated period allowed the order to remain in force.

Page described the agency’s failure to pursue the legal process as an abuse of discretion or what he termed an “embrace of inertia”.

He said such inaction could benefit powerful individuals who stood to gain from judicial decisions, adding that failures by anti-corruption agencies could arise from misconduct by their leadership or deliberate decisions to avoid difficult investigations.

On proposals to introduce digital or random case allocation to reduce human interference in the judiciary, Page supported the idea, saying it could limit opportunities for litigants to influence which judges handle their cases.

However, he cautioned that the system could face challenges because of the heavy workload in Nigerian courts, with litigants potentially manipulating filing dates to influence case assignments.

Page also called for explicit legislation prohibiting government officials from giving judges mansions, sports utility vehicles and other benefits.

He argued that such gifts had become customary under the guise of judicial welfare, despite concerns about their potential influence on judicial independence.

PPLAAF Calls for Comprehensive Judicial Reforms

Meanwhile, PPLAAF Executive Director, Jimmy Kande, said corruption, bribery and undue external pressure continued to undermine Nigeria’s judiciary, with serious consequences for democracy and the rule of law.

“The Nigerian judiciary has been undermined from all sides through corruption, bribery, and undue external pressure. This has long-lasting impacts on democracy, the rule of law, and the daily lives of ordinary Nigerians,” Kande said.

He added that suspected judicial corruption could prevent high-ranking public officials from being convicted of financial crimes, allowing properties allegedly acquired abroad with unexplained wealth to remain beyond the reach of authorities.

Similarly, Programme Manager of the African Centre for Media and Information Literacy, Godwin Onyeacholem, described judicial corruption as a major threat to human rights and democratic development.

“No doubt, the worst offender in Nigeria’s growing human rights violations and stunted democracy is the ruthless corrupt practices that have overwhelmed the country’s judiciary,” he said.

PPLAAF called for comprehensive judicial reforms, including genuine financial independence for the judiciary, stronger independent accountability mechanisms and greater transparency in judicial appointments, budgets, expenditures and contracting.

It also recommended the publication and independent verification of asset declarations by judges and other judicial personnel, sanctions for procedural abuses, and independent vetting of sitting judges and prosecutors under international oversight.

Established in 2017, PPLAAF is a non-governmental organisation dedicated to protecting whistleblowers, advocating for their rights and pursuing strategic litigation when disclosures affect the general interests of African citizens.

 

Share This Article
Leave a Comment