Legal Uncertainty Looms as Analysis Questions Gadzama SAN’s Appeal Options After Supreme Court LPDC Ruling
NewsMediaNG
A constitutional debate has emerged within Nigeria’s legal community following a legal analysis suggesting that Chief Joe-Kyari Gadzama, SAN, may face significant hurdles in challenging the recent decision of the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee (LPDC), which reportedly suspended him from legal practice for three years.
The argument was advanced by legal practitioner, Ikyobo Aondover, Esq., in a detailed commentary examining the implications of the Supreme Court’s decision in Ben Mene-Ejegi v. Nigerian Bar Association & Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee, delivered on June 26, 2026.
According to Aondover, the landmark judgment effectively ended the long-standing practice of filing direct appeals from the LPDC to the Supreme Court.
He noted that for several years, Section 12(7) of the Legal Practitioners Act had provided that appeals against LPDC decisions should proceed directly to the Supreme Court, a position previously affirmed in judicial authorities including Okike v. LPDC (2005) and Akintokun v. LPDC (2014).
However, he argued that the Supreme Court, in the Mene-Ejegi case, held that its appellate jurisdiction under Section 233 of the 1999 Constitution extends only to appeals originating from the Court of Appeal.
According to the analysis, the apex court consequently declared Section 12(7) of the Legal Practitioners Act unconstitutional to the extent that it purported to confer direct appellate jurisdiction on the Supreme Court over LPDC decisions.
Aondover further contended that the ruling has created what he described as a constitutional and statutory vacuum.
While many legal observers initially believed appeals would simply be redirected to the Court of Appeal, he argued that there is currently no express provision in the Legal Practitioners Act or any other Act of the National Assembly conferring appellate jurisdiction on the Court of Appeal over LPDC decisions.
He maintained that this leaves lawyers disciplined by the LPDC, including Gadzama, without a clearly established statutory appellate forum.
The commentary also expressed doubts about the viability of pursuing judicial review before the High Court, arguing that such proceedings may not serve as a substitute for a statutory right of appeal in disciplinary matters handled by the LPDC.
Chief Gadzama had reportedly rejected the LPDC’s findings and indicated his intention to challenge the decision.
However, Aondover argued that any attempt to file a direct appeal at the Supreme Court would likely be struck out for lack of jurisdiction in light of the Mene-Ejegi judgment.
He concluded that only legislative intervention by the National Assembly, through amendments to the Legal Practitioners Act or the Constitution, may resolve the uncertainty surrounding appeals from LPDC decisions.
The legal position, however, is expected to remain a subject of debate among constitutional lawyers, as courts may in future clarify whether alternative legal remedies remain available for persons dissatisfied with LPDC decisions.
As of the time of filing this report, neither the Nigerian Bar Association nor Chief Joe-Kyari Gadzama, SAN, had publicly responded to the constitutional arguments advanced in the commentary beyond his previously reported intention to challenge the LPDC’s decision.




