Alleged $6.23m Fraud: EFCC Urges Court to Reject Emefiele’s No-Case Submission
NewsMediang.com

The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) has urged the Federal Capital Territory High Court in Maitama, Abuja, to dismiss a no-case submission filed by former Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) Governor, Godwin Emefiele, insisting that the evidence presented by the prosecution warrants him entering his defence in the alleged $6.23 million fraud case.
The prosecution made its submission on Tuesday, October 20, 2026, before Justice Hamza Mu’azu, arguing it had established a prima facie case against Emefiele on allegations of criminal breach of trust, forgery, abuse of office, conspiracy, and obtaining money by false pretence.
Emefiele is facing an amended 20-count charge involving the alleged withdrawal of $6.23 million from the CBN and the purported conferment of corrupt advantages in the award of contracts by the apex bank.
Director of Public Prosecution of the Federation, Rotimi Oyedepo, SAN, who appeared for the prosecution, told the court that a no-case submission was not the stage to determine the defendant’s guilt or assess the credibility of witnesses.
According to him, the central question is whether the prosecution has presented sufficient evidence to require the defendant to answer the allegations against him.
Oyedepo maintained that asking Emefiele to enter his defence would not amount to compelling him to prove his innocence but would afford him the opportunity to respond to the evidence presented by the prosecution.
EFCC Alleges Irregularities in CBN Contracts
Addressing the contract-related allegations, Oyedepo identified the key elements of the alleged offences as Emefiele’s position as a public officer, the alleged use of that position and the purported conferment of corrupt advantages on his relations or associates.
He told the court that exhibits bearing Emefiele’s approval signatures, alongside corporate records, allegedly linked him to companies associated with members of his family and associates, including Architekon Nigeria Limited.
The prosecution also argued that the procurement process for contracts valued between $6 million and $10 million was allegedly conducted without the required review by the CBN’s Major Contracts Tender Board.
Oyedepo said contracts exceeding $1 million were expected to pass through the board, which he described as responsible for reviewing procurement proposals and checking whether CBN employees held directorship positions in companies bidding for contracts.
He argued that bypassing the board allegedly deprived the procurement process of the required scrutiny and created room for unfair practices.
Citing the testimony of a procurement department staff member identified as PW10, the prosecution alleged that at least three companies submitted bids for each contract, but officials were instructed to process the bids in favour of a company linked to Emefiele’s associates.
Oyedepo further alleged that the company had access to the CBN’s internal pricing information and subsequently submitted bids matching the bank’s in-house prices, allegedly undermining fair competition among prospective contractors.
“The ingredient of the offence is the unfairness of the process,” he said.
The prosecution argued that the alleged offences were not extinguished by claims that the contracts had been executed or that the funds involved had not been traced directly to Emefiele.
It also alleged that the company concerned had operated for years without securing contracts of the type under investigation until Emefiele became CBN governor, after which it allegedly received all 45 contracts under consideration.
Oyedepo further relied on evidence of transfers from Emefiele’s personal account to the company’s account, arguing that the transactions demonstrated his knowledge of the company and its directors.
He maintained that recommendations made by officials did not amount to final approval, arguing that Emefiele should have referred the contracts back to the relevant board instead of approving them.
“The recommendation would never be an approval,” he told the court.
Prosecution Links $6.23m Withdrawal to Allegedly Forged Letters
On the alleged $6.23 million withdrawal, the EFCC argued that the funds were released from the CBN between February and around June, before Emefiele’s removal from office, purportedly on the strength of letters attributed to former President Muhammadu Buhari and former Secretary to the Government of the Federation, Boss Mustapha.
Oyedepo told the court that testimony from witnesses, including Mustapha and a forensic analyst, indicated that the letters used to facilitate the release of the money were forged.
The prosecution also relied on the testimony of PW15, who reportedly stated that the transaction triggered an automatic system notification to Emefiele after the relevant account went into debit.
Oyedepo alleged that Emefiele failed to take action despite the notification, arguing that the circumstances raised questions of criminal negligence and breach of trust, given his alleged control over the funds.
The prosecution further alleged that the money was released to an individual on Emefiele’s instructions, with part of the funds purportedly used to renovate one of his properties. It said the balance was subsequently recovered from the individual.
Responding to the defence’s argument that the prosecution’s case was speculative, Oyedepo maintained that the evidence presented supported legally permissible inferences.
“There is a difference between speculation and inferences drawn from legally admissible evidence,” he said.
He also argued that where a forged document was used to facilitate a fraudulent transaction and the resulting benefit was traceable to a defendant, the circumstances could support an inference that the defendant forged the document or procured its forgery.
On the defence’s contention that the prosecution had not conducted a forensic examination of Emefiele’s signature, Oyedepo argued that the absence of such an examination did not automatically defeat the forgery allegation, adding that the court could compare disputed signatures in accordance with the law.
He also drew the court’s attention to a Supreme Court decision involving approximately $2 million and certain properties, urging the judge to consider the authority in the context of the prosecution’s arguments.
Emefiele Asks Court to Discharge Him
Opposing the EFCC’s application, defence counsel, Matthew Burkaa, SAN, urged the court to discharge Emefiele, arguing that the prosecution had failed to establish the essential ingredients of the alleged offences.
Burkaa specifically challenged the allegation that his client conferred undue advantage on his wife and associates through the award of CBN contracts.
“My lord, in the entirety of the charge, the prosecution failed to prove that he had conferred undue advantage on his wife and his associates,” the defence counsel said.
The court subsequently stated that the date for its ruling on Emefiele’s no-case submission would be communicated to the parties.
The ruling will determine whether Emefiele will be required to enter his defence or whether the court will uphold his application to be discharged at this stage of the proceedings.
NewsMediang.com will continue to monitor developments in the case.




