Beyond Chatbots: Why Human Customer Service Still Matters in the Age of AI – Olufunmilola ‘Funmie’ Aluko

Beyond Chatbots: Why Human Customer Service Still Matters in the Age of AI - Olufunmilola ‘Funmie’ Aluko
News Media Nigeria

 

*Why the human connection remains the heart of customer service in an increasingly automated world

By Olufunmilola ‘Funmie’ Aluko

On any ordinary day, in any large city, the same moment plays out thousands of times.

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

A woman calls her mobile network because her line has been barred and she cannot reach her children’s school. A man rings a hospital switchboard trying to find out which ward his father has been taken to. A small business owner arrives at the reception desk of a large company, holding an invoice that has remained unpaid for four months.

Advertisement
nlngnlng

A traveller dials an airline hotline at two in the morning from an airport she does not know.

None of them is calm, and none has reason to be.

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

What happens next may depend almost entirely on one person: the agent, operator or receptionist who answers.

If that person listens to the whole problem, takes ownership and clearly explains what will happen next, the customer leaves with something more valuable than a resolution.

She leaves believing the organisation can be trusted.

If not, she may leave with a story she will tell for years.

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

I have spent a quarter of a century in financial services, much of it building and leading brand and customer experience programmes, contact centres and complaints operations, while working with service leaders across the continent.

I have come to believe that this moment is the whole game, regardless of the sector.

The person on the other end of the line is not a cost to be managed. For the customer in that moment, she is the organisation.

As organisations around the world mark Customer Service Week, many of us will picture headsets, call queues and customer-care desks.

But the frontline of an organisation is much wider than its contact centre.

It is the retail hotline and customer-care desk. It is the corporate switchboard that decides whether a caller is helped or passed from extension to extension until she gives up. It is the receptionist who becomes the first face of a headquarters. It is the security officer at the gate, the person answering the general enquiries line of a public agency or the nurse at an admissions desk.

Many of these people never see the inside of a customer experience strategy.

Yet, to the people they serve, they are the brand, the culture and the promise, all at once.

Any organisation with people answering its phones and its doors is in the customer service business, whether it thinks of itself that way or not.

The extra mile starts with the first

This year’s Customer Service Week theme is “The Extra Mile.”

It is a good theme.

I would add only that the extra mile begins with the first.

Anxious customers are rarely looking for grand gestures. They want to know that they can reach someone when it matters and that the person they reach is calm, informed and able to help.

Reachability. Reliability. Ownership.

That is the first mile.

Any organisation that walks it consistently can go the extra mile and be believed. Any organisation that skips it will find that the grand gesture rings hollow.

None of this is simply sentiment.

Research increasingly points in the same direction.

PwC’s 2025 Customer Experience Survey found that 86 per cent of consumers consider human interaction moderately or very important to their experience of a brand. The same survey found that 52 per cent had stopped using or buying from a brand following a bad experience with its products or services.

Gartner, in research involving more than 5,700 customers, found that 64 per cent would prefer companies not to use AI in customer service at all. Their biggest concern was that AI would make it harder to reach a human being.

Even McKinsey, whose research has helped chart the rapid rise of AI in customer care, found that 71 per cent of Gen Z respondents regard a live call as the quickest and easiest way to reach customer care and explain an issue.

The message is clear: technology is changing customer service, but it has not eliminated the need for people.

Gartner predicts that by 2028, no Fortune 500 company will have completely eliminated human customer service. It also estimates that by 2027, half of organisations that had planned significant reductions in their service workforce because of AI will abandon those plans.

The future, in other words, is not necessarily agentless.

It is a future in which fewer, better-equipped people handle the moments that matter most.

The economics of keeping customers

There is also a business case for getting this right.

Bain & Company’s foundational loyalty research, led by Frederick Reichheld, showed that increasing customer retention rates by just five per cent could increase profits by between 25 and 95 per cent.

Every caller who hangs up and every customer who abandons a queue is therefore more than a service statistic.

It could be a customer taking her business elsewhere.

Closer to home, KPMG’s 2025 West Africa Banking Industry Customer Experience Survey, its 19th edition in Nigeria, tells a similar story.

The research drew on more than 35,000 retail customers, 5,000 SMEs and 600 corporates.

Reliability, security and digital access are increasingly regarded as minimum requirements rather than sources of competitive advantage. Customers are also comparing their experiences not only with direct competitors but with the best service they receive anywhere.

A decade ago, the gap between Nigeria’s highest- and lowest-rated retail banks was nearly eight percentage points.

Today, it is under three.

As products and platforms become increasingly similar, the experience becomes one of the few remaining areas where organisations can truly differentiate themselves.

And at the centre of that experience remains the human connection.

Beware the dashboard

One statistic from PwC particularly stays with me.

Nearly nine in ten executives believe customer loyalty has increased in recent years.

Only about four in ten consumers agree.

I keep that statistic close because it captures a risk every leader carries, myself included: the risk of believing our own dashboards.

A waiting time can look perfectly respectable on a monthly report and still feel endless to someone standing in an airport at two in the morning.

The numbers we use to grade ourselves are not always the numbers our customers are living.

Closing that gap requires more than slogans.

In my experience, four choices make a significant difference.

1. Use technology to create more human service

I have championed investment in AI-enabled contact platforms, and I want more good technology across our industries.

A balance checked at midnight, an order tracked within seconds or a password reset without waiting in a queue can all be examples of genuinely good service.

But every automation decision carries another question:

What will we do with the capacity technology frees?

Used well, technology removes routine tasks and allows trained employees to focus on conversations that are complicated, sensitive or frightening.

It can put a customer’s history on an agent’s screen before the call connects, preventing the customer from having to repeat the same story several times.

Used carelessly, however, technology becomes a wall: an endless phone menu, a chatbot with no escape route or a switchboard that rings without an answer.

Technology does not make that choice.

Leaders do.

2. Measure resolution, not just deflection

The second issue is what organisations choose to measure.

Contained and deflected contacts can look like savings, and it is easy to celebrate them.

But deflection and resolution are not the same thing.

A contact can be classified as “contained” simply because the customer gave up.

And a customer who gives up is often deciding, quietly, where to take her business next.

The number every service leader should watch closely is not simply how many contacts were avoided, but how many people abandoned their attempt to reach the organisation.

Alongside that should be three fundamental questions:

Was the matter resolved on the first attempt?

How much effort did it take?

Would the customer speak positively about the organisation afterwards?

Satisfaction scores tell us how we performed.

Resolution and effort tell us what needs to change.

3. Invest in the people behind the technology

The third choice concerns where investment goes.

One of the hardest cases any service leader makes at budget time is the case for people rather than platforms.

I have made it many times.

The ability to remain calm when someone is furious, hear the real concern beneath a complaint and make a quick and fair decision is a genuine skill.

It deserves to be selected for, developed and rewarded as seriously as any software.

This is particularly important for roles organisations often overlook.

Receptionists and switchboard operators are frequently among the least trained and least valued people in the building.

Yet they are its first voice and first face.

Give them the knowledge, authority and respect to help, and they can become some of an organisation’s most powerful brand assets.

An organisation that automates the easy work while underinvesting in the people left with the hard work has simply arranged to fail more expensively.

4. Turn complaints into organisational learning

The fourth question is whether a complaint ends with one customer or becomes a lesson for everyone.

Logging complaints is necessary. In regulated sectors, it is mandatory.

But logging is not learning.

The strongest service organisations I know hold regular sessions with frontline teams because the people answering phones and greeting visitors often hear about an organisation’s problems before anyone else.

Their insights should feed back into the business to help address root causes.

KPMG’s 2025 research illustrates the cost of failing to close that loop.

Of the six pillars of customer experience excellence — Integrity, Resolution, Expectations, Time and Effort, Personalisation and Empathy — Resolution was the lowest-rated pillar among Nigerian retail banking customers for the fifth consecutive year.

Customers cited delays in closing complaints and unclear communication.

In Ghana, KPMG researchers summarised a similar problem in six words:

“Apologies are frequent; accountability is not.”

They linked the problem to frontline teams that lack the authority, tools or visibility needed to drive issues to closure.

As a result, empathy risks becoming a substitute for resolution rather than a pathway to it.

The lesson goes beyond banking.

Resolving one customer’s problem is service.

Fixing the cause so the next thousand customers never experience it is customer experience.

Why this matters in Africa

These choices matter everywhere, but they matter particularly in our markets.

Across Africa, trust in institutions is hard-won and quickly lost.

For many people, a phone call or visit to a reception desk may be their main point of contact with organisations that have real power over their lives — the bank holding their savings, the network carrying their livelihood, the insurer, hospital or government office.

When someone reaches out with a problem and encounters silence, the damage may extend beyond that single afternoon.

It can affect their belief that the institution was ever designed to serve people like them.

Customers also rarely arrive through one polished channel.

They come through USSD codes on basic phones, WhatsApp, physical offices, relatives’ handsets and social media, where a complaint posted at breakfast can become a national conversation by lunchtime.

Serving people consistently across these doors is far harder than serving them through any single channel.

It is the real test of a service operation on the continent.

The organisations that pass that test are those that treat every door as the front door.

Human connection is also a safety issue

There is another reason the human voice matters.

Fraudsters thrive on uncertainty and increasingly impersonate the organisations customers trust.

KPMG reports that Nigerian financial institutions lost ₦52.26 billion to fraud in 2024, up from ₦17.67 billion the previous year.

The research also found that only about one-third of customers feel very secure about how their digital transactions are handled.

A reachable, genuine human being can therefore be one of the strongest protections a customer has — someone who can confirm what is real and what is not.

Being reachable is not only good service.

It is part of keeping people safe.

Regulation sets the floor, not the ceiling

Regulation already recognises much of this.

I have spent much of my career working on consumer protection and closely with regulators.

In Nigeria, the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Act establishes consumer rights, including the right to redress.

Sector regulators, including the Central Bank of Nigeria and the Nigerian Communications Commission, have also developed complaints frameworks around straightforward principles: treat customers fairly, tell them the truth and resolve complaints properly and within reasonable time.

I take those obligations seriously.

But I also believe regulation describes a floor rather than a ceiling.

Fair treatment and timely redress are the minimum any organisation owes the public.

Loyalty is earned by what we do above that line.

What going the extra mile really looks like

What does going above that line look like?

Often, less than people imagine — and more than many organisations currently manage.

It is an agent who listens to the whole problem before reaching for a script.

It is a switchboard operator who connects a caller to someone who can actually help and checks that the connection worked.

It is a receptionist trusted to solve a problem rather than simply redirect it.

It is a promised callback that actually happens.

It is an apology that sounds like a human being wrote it.

Almost none of these things is expensive.

And almost none can be fully automated.

Because what the customer is really testing is whether anyone will take ownership of the problem as though it matters.

A challenge for every organisation

So, this Customer Service Week, I would offer every leader, in every sector, a simple challenge.

Remove one thing that makes your organisation harder to reach.

Sit beside your receptionist or switchboard operator for an hour and ask which callers they struggle to help — and why.

Read ten complaints in full, in the customer’s own words rather than through a management summary.

Give one frontline colleague the authority to settle something they currently have to escalate.

Then call your own organisation’s main number or walk through the front door as a visitor would.

Experience what your customers experience.

I am taking up that challenge myself.

Listen to the person on the other end of the line, from both sides, and ask whether your dashboards tell the same story.

Technology will keep improving, and I will continue to welcome it.

It will answer more simple questions faster and free us to be more human in the moments that matter — if we choose to use it that way.

What technology will not do is care.

Caring remains stubbornly and valuably human.

And in markets where competitors offer much the same products at much the same prices, it may be the most durable advantage any of us has.

The person on the other end of the line is the reason a customer stays.

We would do well to build our organisations around her.

About the Author

Olufunmilola “Funmie” Aluko is a customer experience and brand leader with 25 years of experience in financial services.

A Certified Customer Experience Professional (CCXP), Certified Experience Management Professional (XMP) and Associate Registered Practitioner in Advertising (arpa), she serves on the Africa Regional Council of the Customer Experience Professionals Association (CXPA) and is a member of the American Marketing Association.

She was named among the top 20 global CX leaders in 2022.

Across senior roles at leading banks, Aluko has built customer service, contact centre and complaints management operations, while institutionalising governance across complaint management, service standards and Voice of the Customer programmes.

She has also led award-winning corporate brand campaigns and helped revitalise legacy institutional brands for a digital-first market.

She currently serves as Chief Brand and Marketing Officer and Head of Customer Experience at Union Bank of Nigeria, where she leads the Bank’s brand, marketing, communications and customer experience agenda and oversees the Contact Centre.

She holds an MBA from Warwick Business School, University of Warwick, and a BA (Hons) from Lagos State University.

She is also the voice behind Lessons from Corporate Nigeria, her LinkedIn series of candid reflections on leadership, workplace dynamics and the realities of building a career in corporate Nigeria.

Share This Article
Leave a Comment