Contempt Row: Rivers Judiciary Tackles NBA, Backs Judge Who Jailed Lawyer

Contempt Row: Rivers Judiciary Tackles NBA, Backs Judge Who Jailed Lawyer

News Media Nigeria

Contempt Row: Rivers Judiciary Tackles NBA, Backs Judge Who Jailed Lawyer

 

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

The Rivers State Judiciary has strongly defended the actions of Justice Chinwendu Nwogu following backlash from the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) over the jailing of a lawyer for contempt of court.

Advertisement
nlngnlng

The controversy arose after Justice Nwogu sentenced a legal practitioner, Lovinah Ugbana Benjamin, to three days’ imprisonment for conduct the court described as contempt committed in its presence.

Reacting to the development, the NBA had issued a strongly worded statement titled “Judges Must Not Bully Lawyers Or Abuse Power To Punish For Contempt As a Tool For Intimidation Of Lawyer,” raising concerns over what it viewed as a misuse of judicial authority.

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

However, in a counter statement signed by the Chief Registrar of the Rivers State High Court, David D. Ihua-Maduenyi, the judiciary dismissed the NBA’s position as hasty and based on incomplete information.

According to the statement, Mrs Benjamin, who represented the defendants in the matter, attempted to mislead the court by including facts and evidence in her final written address that were not supported by the record.

“The Learned Counsel when confronted by the court, admitted that what she stated in her final written address was not true and she was unapologetic,” the statement said.

The judiciary maintained that the trial judge followed due process in handling the matter and acted within the powers granted by law in punishing contempt committed in the face of the court.

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

It further explained that although the law permits a sentence of up to three months for such an offence, Justice Nwogu exercised restraint by imposing a three-day jail term, which was later reduced following appeals from members of the bar.

The statement also faulted the NBA’s insistence that such matters should be referred to the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee (LPDC), stressing that this is not mandatory in cases of direct contempt.

Providing further clarification, the judiciary revealed that the lawyer had already been released before the NBA’s national body issued its statement.

It noted that leaders of the NBA Port Harcourt Branch visited the judge, tendered an apology, and requested her release after being fully briefed on the circumstances surrounding the incident.

“The judge having accepted the apology signed a production warrant and upon her production in court and oral application by Mrs Cordelia U. Eke, discharged her unconditionally that same morning,” the statement added.

While expressing surprise at the NBA’s reaction, the judiciary described the association’s demands — including a call for the judge’s probe and a proposed boycott of his court — as excessive and capable of creating unnecessary tension within the legal community.

“The Rivers State Judiciary find the position of the NBA National on the subject very offensive and embarrassingly raising a feeling of acrimony against the Judge in particular, and the High Court bench of Rivers State in general,” the statement read.

The judiciary went on to defend Justice Nwogu’s reputation, describing him as a man of integrity with an unblemished record on the bench.

Despite the sharp exchange, the statement acknowledged the NBA’s role in safeguarding professional standards and reassured that the longstanding relationship between the bench and the bar in Rivers State remains cordial.

“The Bench and the Bar in Rivers State remain veritable partners in the administration of justice,” it stated, noting that the incident would not undermine their cooperation.

Share This Article
Leave a Comment