“Court-Martial, Federal High Court Share Role in Coup Cases” — Legal Expert, Toye Akinlade Explains

A legal practitioner, Toye Akinlade, has clarified the jurisdictional roles of military and civil courts in cases involving military personnel accused of plotting a coup against a democratically elected President, stating that both institutions may be involved depending on the nature of the offence.
According to Akinlade, offences arising from coup plotting often cut across both military discipline and constitutional law.
“Where the conduct amounts to breaches such as mutiny, insubordination, or acts prejudicial to service discipline, a Court-Martial is competent to try such offences under the Armed Forces Act,” he said.
He, however, noted that the jurisdiction of the military tribunal is limited and applies strictly to personnel subject to military law.

“Treason Falls Within Civil Court Authority”
Akinlade emphasised that when the same conduct constitutes an offence against the State, such as treason or a treasonable felony, the matter falls within the jurisdiction of the Federal High Court.
“Coup plotting is not merely a disciplinary issue; it is fundamentally a constitutional offence that threatens the sovereignty of the Federation. In such cases, civil courts are properly vested with jurisdiction,” he explained.“
“No Room for Parallel Proceedings”
The legal expert also warned against the possibility of multiple trials on the same facts, stressing that the law does not permit concurrent proceedings in different courts over identical issues.
“Once a competent court assumes jurisdiction, whether a Court-Martial or a civil court, the other is precluded from entertaining the same matter to avoid abuse of judicial process,” Akinlade stated.“
“Civil Courts Remain Supreme”
Highlighting the hierarchy of judicial authority, Akinlade maintained that civil courts retain supervisory powers over military tribunals.
“Court-Martial proceedings are subject to review by civil courts. This underscores the constitutional supremacy of civil judicial authority, particularly in matters involving national security,” he said.“
“Jurisdiction Is Context-Dependent”
He concluded that the determination of the appropriate forum depends largely on the character of the offence and its implications.
“Coup plotting straddles both military and constitutional provisions. While the Court-Martial may address service-related misconduct, the Federal High Court retains overarching authority in matters of treason and national security,” he added.
The clarification comes amid ongoing discussions on how best to prosecute offences that challenge both military order and Nigeria’s democratic framework, with legal experts insisting on strict adherence to constitutional principles.



