CSMN Rejects Call for INEC Chair’s Resignation, Says Threat Smacks of Bigotry

INEC-Chairman-Joash-Amupitan

News Media Nigeria

CSMN Rejects Call for INEC Chair’s Resignation, Says Threat Smacks of Bigotry

INEC Chairman Joash Amupitan

By the Christian Social Movement of Nigeria (CSMN)

In view of the numerous challenges confronting Nigeria today, the Christian Social Movement of Nigeria (CSMN) urges all patriotic citizens and organisations to exercise restraint in their actions and utterances, particularly those capable of escalating an already fragile national situation.

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

CSMN expresses deep concern over a recent statement credited to the Supreme Council for Shari’ah in Nigeria (SCSN), in which it called for the resignation of the Chairman of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), Prof. Joash Amupitan, describing him as “a threat to the credibility of Nigeria’s democratic process.” The Council further threatened that Muslims would neither recognise nor legitimise any election conducted under his leadership, citing alleged integrity and neutrality concerns.

Advertisement
nlngnlng

This position was reportedly articulated by the President of the SCSN, Sheikh Bashir Umar, in January 2026 during the Council’s Annual Pre-Ramadan Lecture and General Assembly in Abuja, themed “Nigeria’s Future: Faith, Justice, and Leadership.” Earlier, in December 2025, a coalition of 40 Islamic organisations under the Zamfara State Muslims League had similarly criticised what it termed “external pressure” on Shari’ah-related issues, arguing that Shari’ah enjoys constitutional backing within Nigeria’s plural legal system.

CSMN wishes to make it clear that this intervention is neither a defence of the Tinubu administration nor a partisan political position. Rather, it is a principled objection to the increasing use of religion as a tool for intimidation, exclusion, and injustice in national affairs. Religion has, in recent years, been dangerously weaponised in Nigeria, with devastating consequences. Responsible leadership demands de-escalation, not the stoking of sectarian tensions.

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

The appointment of the INEC Chairman is a constitutional responsibility of the President, subject to confirmation by the National Assembly. History provides instructive examples. President Goodluck Jonathan, a Christian, appointed Prof. Attahiru Jega, a Muslim, as INEC Chairman. No religious boycott was threatened. President Muhammadu Buhari, a Muslim, appointed Prof. Mahmood Yakubu, also a Muslim. Again, there was no call for electoral rejection. Today, President Bola Ahmed Tinubu appoints Prof. Joash Amupitan, and suddenly threats of religious non-recognition of elections emerge.

This raises a troubling question: Would the same objections have been raised if the appointee were a northern Muslim? Peace-loving Nigerians know the answer.

The issue for which Prof. Amupitan is being vilified is a legal opinion he expressed, in his professional capacity as a legal practitioner, on a report alleging genocide against Christians in Nigeria. Such an opinion is neither criminal nor unprecedented. Notably, the All Progressives Congress (APC), while in opposition in 2014, raised similar allegations internationally during the Jonathan administration. To now single out a citizen for professional opinion-giving is unjustifiable and selective outrage.

It is therefore evident that the objection to Prof. Amupitan’s appointment has little to do with integrity and much to do with religious and regional bias, particularly his being a Christian. This posture disregards Section 38(1) of the 1999 Constitution, which guarantees freedom of religion to all Nigerians. Intolerance in a multi-ethnic and multi-religious society only fuels division and violence.

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

Christians and other non-Muslims have consistently refrained from threatening the nation when Muslims are appointed to head key national institutions. For instance, Prof. Ishaq Oloyede, a prominent Islamic scholar and official of the Nigerian Supreme Council of Islamic Affairs (NSCIA), heads the Joint Admissions and Matriculation Board (JAMB), which regulates institutions across religious lines, including church-owned universities. Despite his public religious advocacy and statements on contentious issues, Christians did not demand his removal. The same restraint was shown in the case of former Minister Isa Ibrahim Pantami, despite serious allegations against him. This contrast exposes the current demand against Prof. Amupitan as blatant religious bigotry.

Regarding claims that Shari’ah enjoys constitutional backing as part of Nigeria’s plural legal system, CSMN clarifies as follows:

  1. Nigerian law recognises Shari’ah personal law, similar to customary law, but does not approve the enforcement of Shari’ah criminal law as currently practiced in some states.
  2. The 1999 Constitution itself lacks broad national legitimacy, having been imposed without popular consent. The controversial entrenchment of Shari’ah criminal provisions occurred without national consensus.
  3. Eminent legal authorities have consistently questioned the constitutionality of Shari’ah criminal law.

Notable legal opinions include:

  • Prof. Ben Nwabueze, who affirmed that Section 10 of the Constitution renders Shari’ah criminal law unconstitutional.
  • Justice Mohammed Bello, who noted the incompatibility of Shari’ah apostasy laws with Section 38(1) guaranteeing freedom of religion.
  • Mr. Solomon Asemota, SAN, who recalled that the Sardauna of Sokoto deliberately adopted a Penal Code that was inclusive, internationally acceptable, and Qur’an-compliant, a framework under which Northern Nigeria enjoyed peace and stability.

Nigeria’s current challenges demand healing, fairness, and inclusion—not further entrenchment of sectarian divisions. Regions such as the South-West demonstrate that peaceful coexistence across religious lines is both possible and beneficial.

CSMN therefore calls on all Nigerians to redirect their energies towards a more fundamental national conversation: the decommissioning of the 1999 Constitution and the adoption of a genuinely negotiated people’s constitution, or at minimum a return to the 1963 Republican Constitution. Such a reform would promote justice and equity for all Nigerians, irrespective of religion or ethnicity.

We urge the Supreme Council for Shari’ah in Nigeria to join this constructive national cause rather than pursue demands that deepen suspicion and religious intolerance.

God bless Nigeria.

For and on behalf of
Christian Social Movement of Nigeria (CSMN)

Elder Sunday Oibe
Chairman, Governing Council

Bosun Emmanuel
CEO

9 February 2026

Share This Article
Leave a Comment