HOW TO INSTITUTE A CASE IN THE HIGH COURT
The mode of commencement of action refers to the procedure used to bring a case before a court for the first time. In other words, it is the legal process through which a person begins a court case.
In Nigeria, when a person believes that another person has violated their legal rights, they may decide to seek justice through the court. However, the person must follow the procedure prescribed by law before the court can hear the matter.
For example, if Musa lends Ibrahim ₦2 million and Ibrahim refuses to repay the money, Musa may decide to sue him. To begin the case, Musa must file the appropriate court process in the court with jurisdiction to hear the matter.
The method used will depend on the nature of the case and the applicable law.
The main modes of commencing civil proceedings in the High Court are:
1. Writ of Summons.
2. Originating Summons.
3. Originating Motion.
4. Petition.
1. Writ of Summons
A writ of summons is a formal court document used to commence a civil action against a defendant. It informs the defendant that a case has been brought against them and gives notice of the claim they are expected to answer.
A writ of summons is commonly used where there is a dispute between two or more parties that requires the court to examine evidence and determine their rights.
When is a writ of summons used?
A writ of summons is commonly used in cases involving breach of contract, recovery of debt, negligence, fraud and recovery of land, subject to the applicable law and court rules.
Example of recovery of debt
Suppose Musa lends Ibrahim ₦3 million, and Ibrahim promises to repay the money after six months. After the agreed period, Ibrahim refuses to pay despite several demands.
Musa may decide to take the matter to court to recover his money. If the claim falls within the jurisdiction of the High Court and the applicable rules require a writ, Musa will commence the action by filing a writ of summons.
Example of breach of contract
Musa agrees to buy a vehicle from Ibrahim for ₦5 million. Musa pays the money, but Ibrahim refuses to deliver the vehicle or refund the payment.
Musa may institute an action against Ibrahim to recover his money or seek another appropriate remedy.
Documents required
Depending on the applicable High Court rules, the claimant may be required to file:
Writ of Summons.
Statement of Claim.
List of Witnesses.
Witness Statements on Oath.
List of Documents to be Relied Upon.
Copies of relevant documents.
The Statement of Claim explains the facts of the case, while the other documents identify the evidence and witnesses the claimant intends to rely upon.
After the required processes have been filed, the defendant must be served in accordance with the law and given an opportunity to respond.
A writ of summons is particularly useful where the parties disagree about the facts and the court needs to examine their evidence before reaching a decision.
2. Originating Summons
Originating summons is a court process used to commence proceedings where the principal issue concerns the interpretation of a written law, contract, will or other document, particularly where there is unlikely to be a substantial dispute about the facts.
It allows the court to determine a legal question without necessarily conducting a full trial involving extensive oral evidence.
When is originating summons used?
It may be used in appropriate cases involving the interpretation of statutes, contracts, wills and other written instruments.
Example
Musa and Ibrahim enter into a written agreement stating that Ibrahim must pay Musa ₦500,000 every year for five years.
After making the first payment, Ibrahim argues that he is only required to pay once. Musa insists that the agreement requires annual payments for five years.
Both parties agree that the document is genuine and that they signed it. Their disagreement concerns the meaning of the agreement.
In these circumstances, originating summons may be appropriate because the main issue is the interpretation of the written agreement.
However, if the parties disagree substantially about whether the agreement was signed or whether fraud occurred, originating summons may not be the appropriate procedure.
The court must consider the nature of the dispute and the applicable rules.
The important point is that originating summons is generally suitable where the main question is one of legal interpretation and the material facts are substantially undisputed.
3. Originating Motion
An originating motion is a court process used to commence proceedings where the applicable law or court rules authorize or require that procedure.
It is not a process that a lawyer can choose freely for every case. The nature of the matter and the applicable law determine whether it is appropriate.
When is originating motion used?
It may be used in certain judicial-review proceedings and other matters where the law prescribes that procedure.
Example of judicial review
Suppose a public authority makes a decision that affects a person’s rights. The person believes that the decision was made unlawfully and wishes to challenge it in court.
The person may apply for judicial review, provided the legal requirements are satisfied.
Depending on the applicable rules, the proceedings may be commenced by originating motion or another prescribed process.
The remedies available in judicial-review proceedings may include:
Certiorari: An order used to quash an unlawful decision.
Mandamus: An order compelling a public authority to perform a public duty where the legal requirements are satisfied.
Prohibition: An order preventing a body or authority from continuing proceedings outside its lawful powers.
Originating processes may also be used in appropriate fundamental-rights proceedings, subject to the Fundamental Rights (Enforcement Procedure) Rules 2009 and other applicable law.
For example, a person who alleges unlawful detention may approach the appropriate court to seek enforcement of their fundamental rights.
The correct procedure must be followed, and the applicant must provide the necessary evidence.
4. Petition
A petition is a formal written document presented to a court to seek a particular remedy in proceedings for which the law prescribes or authorizes that procedure.
It sets out the petitioner’s complaint, the relevant facts, the grounds for the claim and the relief sought.
A petition is used for particular types of proceedings rather than every ordinary civil claim.
When is a petition used?
A. Matrimonial proceedings
A petition is used in matrimonial proceedings where required by the Matrimonial Causes Act and the applicable rules.
For example, if a husband or wife wishes to obtain a decree of dissolution of marriage, the prescribed matrimonial procedure must be followed.
The petition sets out the relevant facts and the grounds upon which the petitioner seeks the court’s intervention.
B. Election petitions
An election petition is used to challenge an election in circumstances permitted by the Constitution, electoral legislation and the applicable election-petition rules.
For example, a candidate who believes that an election was conducted contrary to the law may challenge the result by presenting an election petition, provided the legal requirements are satisfied.
Election petitions have strict procedural requirements, including time limits. Failure to comply with those requirements may affect the petition.
Differences Between the Four Modes
Mode Meaning and purpose Example
Writ of Summons Used to commence many ordinary civil claims, particularly where facts are disputed. Recovery of debt or damages for negligence.
Originating Summons Used mainly to determine legal questions involving the interpretation of written documents or laws where facts are substantially undisputed. Interpretation of a written contract.
Originating Motion Used where the applicable law or court rules prescribe or authorize the procedure. Certain judicial-review proceedings.
Petition Used for particular proceedings prescribed by law. Matrimonial proceedings or an election petition.
Factors That Determine the Appropriate Mode of Commencement
Before commencing an action, a lawyer must consider the following matters.
1. Nature of the case: The lawyer must understand the dispute and identify the appropriate procedure.
2. Disputed facts: Where there is a substantial dispute about the facts, a writ of summons will generally be more appropriate than originating summons.
3. Relief sought: The lawyer must identify what the claimant wants the court to do, such as ordering repayment of a debt, awarding damages or interpreting a contract.
4. Applicable law: Some laws prescribe a particular method of commencing proceedings. The lawyer must comply with those requirements.
5. Jurisdiction: The lawyer must ensure that the court has jurisdiction to hear the case. Using the correct originating process cannot give jurisdiction to a court that does not possess it.
6. Court rules: Different High Courts in Nigeria operate under their respective procedural rules. A lawyer must consult the rules applicable to the particular court.
What Happens If the Wrong Process Is Used?
If an action is commenced using an inappropriate process, the defendant may raise an objection.
The court will consider the nature of the defect, the applicable law and the circumstances of the case. Depending on those factors, the court may permit an amendment, direct the adoption of an appropriate procedure, or set aside or strike out the proceedings.
The result depends on the particular circumstances. A procedural defect should also be distinguished from a lack of jurisdiction, which cannot ordinarily be cured merely by changing the originating process.
Conclusion
The mode of commencement of action is an important aspect of civil procedure because every case must be brought before the court in the manner prescribed by law.
The four principal modes are writ of summons, originating summons, originating motion and petition.
A writ of summons is commonly used for ordinary civil claims, especially where facts are disputed. Originating summons is suitable for certain legal questions where the material facts are substantially undisputed. Originating motion is used where the law or court rules authorize or require it, while a petition is used for particular proceedings prescribed by law.
A lawyer must therefore examine the nature of the case, the relief sought, the applicable law and the rules of the particular court before deciding how to commence an action.
By God fearing Man.




