Lawyer Questions Practice of Remanding Suspects Before Bail Rulings
A legal practitioner, Barrister Wisdom Chude, has criticised the practice of courts remanding defendants in correctional facilities while reserving rulings on their bail applications for a later date, describing the procedure as inconsistent with the constitutional right to personal liberty.
Chude argued that it is both procedurally questionable and potentially offensive to fundamental rights for courts, particularly the Federal High Court, to order the remand of an accused person simply because a security agency has filed charges, before determining whether the individual qualifies for bail.
According to him, the practice can result in citizens spending days or even weeks in custody over allegations that may ultimately lack legal merit.
“How do you remand a citizen to prison simply because a security agency filed a charge against them when that charge may ultimately have no merit?” he queried.
The lawyer noted that security agencies occasionally file charges that are later found to be legally defective or unsupported by evidence, warning that automatic remand orders could expose innocent citizens to unnecessary detention.
He illustrated the concern with a hypothetical scenario in which an individual is arrested for an offence that has no legal basis, only to spend several days in prison before a court eventually grants bail.
According to Chude, Nigeria’s justice system should be reformed to ensure that bail applications are heard and determined on the same day as arraignment wherever possible.
He argued that if a court decides to deny bail after considering the application, such a decision would be based on a reasoned judicial determination rather than a temporary remand pending a future ruling.
“Our justice system should be improved to allow bail applications to be heard on the day of arraignment. If bail is then denied, it would be on the basis of a considered ruling,” he stated.
Chude maintained that situations where courts eventually grant bail after defendants have already spent days in custody undermine the principle that every accused person is presumed innocent until proven guilty.
The lawyer said his comments were prompted by reports concerning journalist Princewill, who was allegedly arrested by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) and remanded pending the court’s consideration of his bail application.
The development has reignited discussions among legal practitioners and civil rights advocates over the balance between judicial discretion, effective criminal prosecution, and the protection of constitutional rights.
While courts retain the authority to remand defendants in accordance with existing laws and procedural rules, critics continue to argue that faster determination of bail applications would better safeguard the rights and liberties of accused persons awaiting trial.




