No Evidence:Court Dismisses Ex-OOU Lecturer’s N2bn Suit Over Alleged Promotion Denial

No Evidence:Court Dismisses Ex-OOU Lecturer’s N2bn Suit Over Alleged Promotion Denial

News Media Nigeria

An Industrial Court sitting in Ibadan, Oyo State, has dismissed a N2 billion damages suit filed by a retired lecturer of Olabisi Onabanjo University (OOU), Dr Raymond Adegboyega, against the institution over allegations of prolonged denial of promotion and other employment-related grievances.

Adegboyega, who recently retired from the Department of Banking and Finance at the Ogun State-owned university, had approached the court seeking N2 billion in damages, alleging that the institution had denied him promotion for decades despite his years of service.

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

The former lecturer, through his counsel, Mr Osuolale Asanike, argued that after his employment by the university in 1982, he was promoted only once in 2001 from Lecturer II to Lecturer I and remained on that rank until his retirement in 2022.

Advertisement
nlngnlng

According to him, the university’s alleged refusal to promote him was influenced by ethnic bias because he was not an indigene of Ogun State.

He accused the institution of nepotism, segregation and ethnic discrimination, claiming the situation subjected him to psychological trauma throughout his years of service.

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

Adegboyega further alleged that he never proceeded on annual leave during his time at the institution and was not paid leave entitlements. He therefore sought an order directing payment of accumulated leave allowances calculated according to what he described as his deserved promotion levels.

The claimant also asked the court to compel payment of deductions allegedly made from his salaries but not remitted to the university’s cooperative society, as well as outstanding deductions meant for the Academic Staff Union of Universities (ASUU).

He additionally sought a declaration directing the institution to compute his pension and gratuity using the promotions he believed he ought to have earned.

However, counsel to the university, Messrs Felix Ogunmade and Daniel Ola, urged the court to dismiss all the claims, describing them as baseless, speculative and unsupported by evidence.

Advertisement
Ad imageAd image

Lead counsel Ogunmade argued that promotions at the university are earned and based on measurable criteria, including academic publications, professional affiliations and recommendations from departmental and faculty structures.

He further told the court that Adegboyega was eventually recommended for promotion to the position of Senior Lecturer in 2019, but the process was reportedly interrupted following a petition by a student.

On the issue of pensions, the university maintained that pensions are handled by pension fund administrators and not directly by institutions.

The defence also argued that the claimant voluntarily chose not to take annual leave and could therefore not convert such leave periods into financial claims.

Delivering judgment, Justice J.D. Peters upheld the arguments of the university and ruled that promotion remains the exclusive prerogative of an employer.

The judge held that employees cannot automatically claim entitlement to promotion based solely on personal assessment of competence or years of service.

“Promotion is not a right but rather a privilege which must be earned,” the judge ruled.

Justice Peters further held that the claimant failed to provide evidence proving that he met the conditions necessary for promotion.

The court also dismissed the N2 billion damages claim, relying on the legal principle established in UAC v MacFoy, noting that a claim without a valid legal foundation cannot stand.

The judge subsequently dismissed all other reliefs sought by the claimant, ruling that Adegboyega failed to establish his case with credible and admissible evidence.

“I dismiss the case of the claimant in its entirety for lack of proof by cogent, credible and admissible evidence,” the court held.

I’ve rewritten it in a NewsMediaNG-style format with multiple headline options and a polished full report ready for publishing.

Share This Article
Leave a Comment