A senior lecturer at the University of Derby, Russell Cherrington, has lost his appeal against his dismissal after the Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the university’s decision to sack him over language found to be misogynistic, transphobic and unprofessional.
Cherrington, who taught film studies, argued that his comments were protected under his right to freedom of expression as guaranteed by Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights. However, the tribunal rejected his claim and ruled that the university acted lawfully in dismissing him.
The case stemmed from complaints by four students enrolled in the university’s Film and High End TV programme. The complaints emerged following poor results in the National Student Survey, prompting the university to investigate the lecturer’s conduct.
Cherrington was suspended on December 18, 2023, and a subsequent investigation concluded in 2024 found multiple instances of what the university described as gross misconduct.
The tribunal found that Cherrington referred to women in his classes almost exclusively as “females,” describing the language as misogynistic. It also cited comments he made while assessing a student’s music video, in which he reportedly said the lead actress was “not attractive enough for the role.”
Although Cherrington admitted referring to female students as “females,” he said he did so because he did not know their names and insisted he did not believe his comments about the actress were offensive.
The tribunal also heard that Cherrington told a student, “If you had worn that nail polish back in the day, you would have been called a p**f,” a remark the panel considered inappropriate.
He was further accused of referring to a transitioning student as a “troublesome trans kid.” Cherrington denied making the comment but said he had mentioned a transitioning student while explaining that he would support all students regardless of background.
The lecturer also rejected claims that he made ableist remarks after allegedly saying universities were “becoming a care home for people with disabilities.”
Despite having what the tribunal described as a previously unblemished disciplinary record, Cherrington was dismissed in April 2024 for using inappropriate and unprofessional language.
During the disciplinary process, he submitted a list of eight students whom he said could testify to his conduct and teaching style. However, the disciplinary panel decided not to contact them, concluding that positive testimonials would not outweigh the specific allegations under investigation.
After failing to overturn his dismissal before an employment tribunal, Cherrington appealed, claiming his academic freedom and right to free expression had been infringed.
Employment Appeal Tribunal Judge Justice Cavanagh dismissed the appeal, ruling that the European Convention on Human Rights does not automatically have to be considered in every unfair dismissal case.
The judge said the original tribunal had properly considered whether the university breached its freedom of speech obligations and concluded that it had not, adding that the appeal was therefore dismissed.




