A former student of the Federal University of Technology, Akure, Mr. Adebayo Afolabi Victor, has secured a landmark victory at the Supreme Court after a 19-year battle over the classification of his university degree.
Victor, who graduated from FUTA in 2007 with a Second Class Lower Division in Mechanical Engineering, had consistently maintained that his academic performance entitled him to a Second Class Upper Division. He repeatedly requested that the university review and remark some of his examination scripts, but his requests were not granted.
After years of unsuccessful efforts to resolve the matter internally, Victor approached the Federal High Court in 2011, seeking an order compelling the university to remark the disputed scripts and issue a corrected transcript and certificate. The case experienced several twists, including an initial dismissal, a successful appeal, a retrial, and further appeals that eventually took the matter to the Supreme Court.
During the course of the litigation, the court ordered FUTA to have the scripts remarked by independent assessors. The outcome vindicated Victor’s long-held position, as the review revealed that he had indeed earned a Second Class Upper Division. The university subsequently corrected his records and issued a new transcript and certificate reflecting the upgraded degree classification.
In its judgment delivered on December 12, 2025, the Supreme Court held that while universities enjoy academic autonomy, they also owe students a duty of care in the administration of academic matters. The apex court ruled that institutions must handle students’ complaints fairly and diligently and cannot hide behind academic independence when genuine grievances arise.
Delivering the lead judgment, Justice Helen Moronkeji Ogunwumiju emphasized that courts would not interfere with academic decisions themselves but could intervene where negligence, administrative failure, or unfair treatment is established.
The Supreme Court further found that FUTA’s prolonged failure to address Victor’s complaints caused him significant hardship, emotional distress, and the loss of opportunities, including a fully funded scholarship he claimed to have missed due to the incorrect degree classification. Consequently, the court increased the damages earlier awarded by the lower court from ₦500,000 to ₦18 million and awarded an additional ₦2 million as litigation costs, bringing the total compensation to ₦20 million.
One of the most remarkable aspects of the case is that Victor, who is not a lawyer, prosecuted the matter himself through multiple levels of the judicial system and ultimately prevailed at the nation’s highest court.
The decision in Victor v. FUTA (2026) 8 NWLR (Pt. 2044) 33 is being widely regarded as a significant precedent on students’ rights, university accountability, and the duty of care educational institutions owe to their students.




