“You Must Serve for 8 Years” – Court Navy Officer Loses Bid to Resign After Five Years as Industrial Court Upholds Service Rule, Awards ₦2m Costs Against the Officer
The National Industrial Court of Nigeria has upheld the Nigerian Navy’s requirement that officers enlisted under the Direct Short Service Commission (DSSC) must complete an initial eight-year service period before applying for voluntary resignation.
The court, presided over by its President, Justice Benedict Kanyip, OFR, dismissed a suit filed by naval officer Anthony Oluwafemi Awoyemi, challenging the Chief of Naval Staff’s and the Nigerian Navy’s refusal to approve his application to leave service before completing the mandatory period.
In its judgment delivered on November 12, 2026, the court held that officers who voluntarily accept commissions under the DSSC scheme are bound by the applicable terms and conditions of service, including the stipulated minimum engagement period.
Anthony was commissioned into the Nigerian Navy on March 20, 2015, under Direct Short Service Commission Course 22 as a Surgeon Sub-Lieutenant.
According to court documents, he submitted a voluntary resignation application dated September 28, 2020, seeking to leave the service effective November 30, 2020.
However, the naval authorities rejected the application in a letter dated November 2, 2020, explaining that he had served for only about five years and had not fulfilled the mandatory eight-year initial engagement.
He subsequently wrote another letter dated February 18, 2021, reiterating his intention to leave the service.
Dissatisfied with the Navy’s decision, Anthony approached the court, seeking declarations that he had a constitutional right to voluntarily resign and that his resignation application was valid and effective upon receipt by the appropriate authorities.
His counsel argued that Section 306 of the 1999 Constitution, as amended, guarantees public officers the right to resign once their resignation letters are received by the appropriate authority.
The claimant also argued that the Navy’s refusal to approve his resignation amounted to forced labour and violated his constitutional rights and relevant International Labour Organisation conventions.
However, counsel to the defendants, Al-Ameen Abubakar, maintained that members of the Armed Forces cannot exercise an unrestricted right to resign without complying with the service conditions governing their engagement.
The Nigerian Navy relied on Condition 06.05 of the Harmonised Terms and Conditions of Service for Officers, 2017 (Revised), which provides for an initial eight-year engagement for officers commissioned under the DSSC scheme.
Why the Court Dismissed the Suit
In his judgment, Justice Kanyip first considered whether the action was statute-barred under the Public Officers Protection Act.
The court held that Anthony’s cause of action arose on November 2, 2020, when the Navy formally rejected his resignation application.
However, he did not institute the suit until May 15, 2026, more than five years after the rejection.
The judge consequently held that the action was statute-barred, noting that it was filed outside the three-month limitation period prescribed by the law.
On the substantive issues, Justice Kanyip held that constitutional provisions relating to resignation, the prohibition of forced labour and the responsibilities of the Armed Forces must be interpreted together rather than in isolation.
The court considered Sections 1, 34, 217, 254C and 306 of the 1999 Constitution, alongside International Labour Organisation Conventions 29 and 105.
Justice Kanyip reasoned that Anthony voluntarily joined the Nigerian Navy under the DSSC scheme and accepted the conditions attached to his commission.
He therefore held that the naval authorities were entitled to insist on compliance with the agreed eight-year initial service commitment before considering his application for voluntary resignation.
The court also rejected the argument that the Navy’s refusal amounted to forced or compulsory labour.
According to the judgment, Anthony was not being compelled to remain in the service indefinitely, as the naval authorities had informed him that he could submit another resignation application after completing the mandatory eight-year period.
The court subsequently dismissed the suit and awarded ₦2 million in costs against the claimant in favour of the Chief of Naval Staff and the Nigerian Navy, directing that the amount be paid within 30 days.
The judgment reinforces the enforceability of the Nigerian Navy’s minimum service requirement for officers commissioned under the Direct Short Service Commission scheme.
NewsMediang.com reports that the ruling also clarifies the relationship between the constitutional right of public officers to resign and the specific service obligations voluntarily accepted by members of the Armed Forces.
Sources: National Industrial Court of Nigeria judgment and official court report. nicnadr.gov.ng +2




